TY - JOUR
T1 - A Systematic Review of the Use of Electronic Nose and Tongue Technologies for Detecting Food Contaminants
AU - Zia Ul Haq, Muhammad
AU - Singh, Baljit
AU - Fuku, Xolile
AU - Barhoum, Ahmed
AU - Tian, Furong
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2025 by the authors.
PY - 2025/7
Y1 - 2025/7
N2 - Sensor operations in the food industry are faced with several major challenges, including in sensitivity, selectivity, accuracy and rapid detection. Among emerging technologies, e-nose and e-tongue systems have attracted much attention from researchers. This review examines 112 studies published from 2004 to 2025, and examines the functionalities and performance in detecting various food product-associated analytes. The sensitivity of e-nose and e-tongue systems was analyzed using various data processing techniques. Recent research and development in leading countries (i.e., China, United Kingdom, Columbia, India, Portugal, Spain, Hungary, Ireland) was examined. The findings indicate that principal component analysis (PCA) was the most widely used technique, while more articles were published in 2021. Worldwide research contributions showed China at the forefront of e-nose studies (26.7%) and Spain leading in e-tongue research (30%). The highest sensitivity values were 99.0% for the e-nose in 2015 and 100% for the e-tongue in 2012. In specific applications, the e-nose achieved a maximum average sensitivity of 15% in apple analysis, while the e-tongue achieved a maximum average sensitivity of 40.5% in water samples. Furthermore, the review presents an in-depth discussion of key parameters, including food sample types, citation rates, analysis techniques, accuracy, and sensitivity, with graphical representations for enhanced clarity.
AB - Sensor operations in the food industry are faced with several major challenges, including in sensitivity, selectivity, accuracy and rapid detection. Among emerging technologies, e-nose and e-tongue systems have attracted much attention from researchers. This review examines 112 studies published from 2004 to 2025, and examines the functionalities and performance in detecting various food product-associated analytes. The sensitivity of e-nose and e-tongue systems was analyzed using various data processing techniques. Recent research and development in leading countries (i.e., China, United Kingdom, Columbia, India, Portugal, Spain, Hungary, Ireland) was examined. The findings indicate that principal component analysis (PCA) was the most widely used technique, while more articles were published in 2021. Worldwide research contributions showed China at the forefront of e-nose studies (26.7%) and Spain leading in e-tongue research (30%). The highest sensitivity values were 99.0% for the e-nose in 2015 and 100% for the e-tongue in 2012. In specific applications, the e-nose achieved a maximum average sensitivity of 15% in apple analysis, while the e-tongue achieved a maximum average sensitivity of 40.5% in water samples. Furthermore, the review presents an in-depth discussion of key parameters, including food sample types, citation rates, analysis techniques, accuracy, and sensitivity, with graphical representations for enhanced clarity.
KW - analytical methods
KW - contaminants
KW - data processing techniques
KW - e-nose
KW - e-tongue
KW - electrochemical sensor
KW - food safety
KW - principal component analysis (PCA)
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105011956925
U2 - 10.3390/chemosensors13070262
DO - 10.3390/chemosensors13070262
M3 - Review article
AN - SCOPUS:105011956925
SN - 2227-9040
VL - 13
JO - Chemosensors
JF - Chemosensors
IS - 7
M1 - 262
ER -